Which type of foam is most effective for fire suppression?

Film-forming foam is highly effective for fire suppression because it creates a thin film that blocks oxygen from reaching the fuel surface, thereby suffocating the fire and preventing re-ignition. This type of foam also has the ability to seal a burning liquid surface, which is crucial for suppressing flammable liquid fires. The film-forming properties enhance its performance in dealing with hydrocarbons, allowing it to form an effective barrier and suppress volatile vapors that can fuel a fire.

In comparison, while alcohol-resistant foam has specific applications for fires involving polar solvents, it is not as universally effective as film-forming foam. Protein foam, primarily used for flammable liquids in a different context, might not provide the rapid suppression needed for certain scenarios. Class A foam is beneficial for wildfires and ordinary combustibles but does not have the same fire-blocking capability offered by film-forming foams for liquid fuels. Thus, the versatility and effectiveness in a broad range of fire scenarios make film-forming foam the most advantageous choice for fire suppression.